Atlanta Vs Pittsburgh Car Insurance

Get Your Free Quote Today

Enter your ZIP code to find the best insurance rates in your area

Cheapest Car Insurance 2025: Atlanta Vs Pittsburgh?

Location Pin Icon

Enter your ZIP code below to discover companies offering the most affordable
auto insurance in your area.

Atlanta Car Insurance in 2025

Atlanta residents are battling some of the highest auto insurance costs across the nation this year. A full-coverage insurance policy for Atlanta is about $3,810 per year that equates to about $318 per month.

The minimum liability insurance will cause drivers to pay between 802-$1,115 per year depending on their neighborhood and insurance company.

The increase isn't a new phenomenon. Georgia experienced an increase of 20% between 2023 and 2024 and experts anticipate an 8 percent increase by 2025. This has pushed the cost of driving for many motorists over the average national.

Why is the cost of insurance so high in Atlanta?

  • Traffic and congestion are a major issue
  • A high volume of claims
  • Risk of vandalism and theft
  • The rate of inflation in medical and repair expenses
  • Zip-code sensitive

Pittsburgh Car Insurance in 2025

Pittsburgh car insurance with affordable rate: As opposed to Atlanta, Pittsburgh offers much lower rates on car insurance by 2025. A typical full-coverage insurance policy for Pittsburgh is between $1,416 to $1,933 per year. This is based on the insurance company and insurance coverage levels. This is roughly $118-$161 monthly. For drivers that opt for minimum liability insurance that is required by law, the rates could range from $429-$566 per year, which is less than half the amount that many Atlanta motorists are paying for similar coverage.

It's interesting to note that after a massive 38% increase in the rate of Pennsylvania in 2024, the Pittsburgh market remains extremely competitive. It's due in part to the state's regulatory framework, which has kept further rate hikes off for 2025 by limiting them to 3-4 percent.

What is the reason why Pittsburgh is more affordable?

  • Reduced traffic congestion
  • Lower crime rates
  • A wider range of insurance options are available
  • Protecting consumers

Comparing prices side-by-side: Atlanta vs. Pittsburgh

City Full Coverage Avg Liability-Only Avg Estimated Monthly Cost
Atlanta $3,810/year $802-$1,115/year Full: ~$318/mo, Liability: ~$67-$93/mo
Pittsburgh $1,416-$1,933/year $429-$566/year Full: ~$118-$161/mo, Liability: ~$36-$47/mo

Why the Price Gap Is So Large

  • The driving conditions: Atlanta’s highways vs. Pittsburgh’s slower streets.
  • Market structure for insurance: More competitive market in Pittsburgh.
  • ZIP-code pricing model: Greater variation in Atlanta due to crime and claims.
  • Regulations: Georgia allows easier rate increases than Pennsylvania.

Tips to Save on Car Insurance in Both Cities

  • Get quotes from a variety of companies
  • Bundle insurance policies
  • Utilize safe-driving applications (telematics)
  • Increase your deductible
  • Keep your record clean
  • Credit score is important

Conclusion

The winner in 2025 is obvious: Pittsburgh drivers pay far cheaper car insurance compared to those from Atlanta. The full-coverage rate for Pittsburgh generally stays at or below $2000 per year. However, most Atlanta drivers pay almost twice as much.

Although certain Atlanta residents can still score great deals when shopping around and taking advantage of discount offers, the typical policyholder in Pittsburgh gets better base rates as well as a more competitive insurance market and better price stability due to the tighter supervision of state agencies.

If affordable insurance for your car is an important concern for this year, Pittsburgh provides a more welcoming area for your pocket.

FAQs

Which city has cheaper car insurance in 2025?

Pittsburgh has significantly lower full-coverage and liability-only rates than Atlanta in 2025.

Why are Atlanta's insurance costs so high?

Atlanta’s higher traffic, theft rates, medical/repair costs, and ZIP-code pricing models all contribute to higher premiums.

Can I save money on car insurance in Atlanta?

Yes, through bundling, safe driving apps, shopping around, and increasing your deductible.

How much can I expect to pay for car insurance in Pittsburgh?

Roughly $1,416 to $1,933 per year for full coverage, and $429 to $566 per year for liability-only coverage.